I think this winter weather is making the normally super-friendly Sconnies get a bit mean-spirited (generally folks really are nicer here). I hope it is the weather.
I’m a proud member of the
Leinie Lodge. I enjoy beer from
Leinenkugel’s, the seventh-oldest brewery in the U.S., and one of the brands of choice in Wisconsin. I enjoyed it before I lived here, especially on numerous
Midwest flights back and forth between Wisconsin and Philadelphia. It reminds me of
Yuengling in many ways. Both breweries are intertwined with the culture and history of the state. I remember the day I was shocked to discover it was
owned by Miller, and then relieved to find out that the Leinenkugel family still had day to day control. If anything, Miller has increased the distribution area immensely, which is generally a good thing for beer drinkers. Sunset Wheat was available at my local distributor in Havertown, PA, and at the corner store on Spruce Street when I lived in Rittenhouse in Center City Philadelphia.
Today I received an invitation to participate in a Leinie’s survey that asked for feedback on what must be a new marketing strategy for text on the labels or packaging. I’ll save my comments until after the text:
Leinenkugel’s – Made By Passionate Craftsmen
Everyday a new “craft microbrew” enters the market with new flavors and trendy names. But do they really have brewing credentials? We don’t think so. They haven’t put in the time and effort to learn what a beer drinker really wants in a beer.
Leinenkugel’s is the true craft beer. Brewed by 73 passionate craftsmen in the small community of Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin – the same community where the Leinenkugel founded it in 1867. Unaffected by outside influences, their attention to detail and dedication to making great craft beers is one of the main reasons that Leinenkugel’s continues to define what makes beer great. Meticulously blending the finest hand-selected ingredients and brewing in small batches, Leinenkugel’s has refused to compromise.
Leinenkugel’s – Made By Passionate Craftsmen
I have no issue with the second paragraph. I think Leinie’s should be proud of its heritage and continued commitment to quality and small batches. They should promote it. Let people know why your beer is great.
I was extremely disappointed, however, in the first paragraph. I think it is arrogant and somewhat obnoxious. Why does Leinie’s have to put down all other craft brewers by making very generalized statements about the quality of other craft brews and brewers. Leinie’s insinuates that other craft brewers don’t care about their beer, don’t know how to brew, and throw crappy product on the market just to make money. Why? Where is the midwestern congeniality? I don’t know what Leinie’s thinks it will gain from this, other than irritating a lot of beer drinkers who really love local craft brews. If Leinenkugel wants folks to understand that it is a small brewery that makes exciting beers based on over 140 years of experience, then just say so. Don’t insult other breweries for no reason. If anything, Leinie’s should be trying to distinguish itself from the often bland products put out by the big breweries.
This reminds me of the
Minhas Craft Brewery’s Lazy Mutt Farmhouse Ale television commercials that played incessantly in the Madison market during football bowl season. They featured animated dogs that run around harassing a spotted cow in a thinly-veiled swipe at
New Glarus Brewing Company’s popular
Spotted Cow brew. I have not sampled Lazy Mutt yet, partly because there are other more seasonal beers I like to drink in subzero weather, but also because
initial reviews have not made me want to run out and buy it. Again, I wonder why Minhas felt the need to attack another popular local Wisconsin brewery in promoting its own product. I personally do not think this is the proper spirit for a craft brewery. Why not instead make a great product that is distinguished from the others and promote it on that strength? Leave the “better than you”
commercials to Miller and Anheuser-Busch.
Just annoys me to see this behavior from smaller outfits. I guess one could argue that neither Leinie’s or Minhas are really “craft” breweries anyway and are just using the term as a marketing ploy, so maybe I’m getting worked up for nothing.